Certificates of Insurance for Contractors in New York: What a COI Proves and What It Doesn’t

If you’re a contractor, sooner or later a general contractor, property manager or town building department will ask for a certificate of insurance, often called a COI. It’s a short document that shows you have certain policies in force. Knowing what it does and doesn’t do can save you a delayed job or a coverage gap.

What a COI is

New York Insurance Law section 501 defines a certificate of insurance as a document prepared or issued by an insurer or insurance producer as evidence of property/casualty coverage. It summarizes your policies, such as the insurer, policy numbers, dates and limits. It is not the policy itself, and it is not a binder (NY DFS).

What a COI can’t do

Under Insurance Law section 502(c), a certificate cannot amend, extend or alter the coverage in the policy it refers to, and it cannot give anyone rights beyond what the policy expressly provides. New York also bars anyone from willfully requiring certificate language that the policy doesn’t actually contain (section 502(b)), and a certificate required as a condition of a contract has to be the insurer’s own form or a standard form approved by the Superintendent (section 502(a)).

Certificate holder vs. additional insured

Being named as the certificate holder means a party receives proof of your coverage. It doesn’t make them insured under your policy. If your contract says the general contractor or owner must be an additional insured, that status has to come from the policy itself, usually through an endorsement. Ask for the endorsement to be in place before work starts, not just a line on the certificate.

Workers’ comp proof is different in New York

The NY Workers’ Compensation Board says ACORD forms are not acceptable proof of New York workers’ compensation coverage under Workers’ Compensation Law section 57. For a government permit, license or contract, the usual proof is Form C-105.2 from a private carrier (or Form U-26.3 from the State Insurance Fund), and Form DB-120.1 for disability and Paid Family Leave benefits. The Board says only licensed carriers and their licensed NY agents can issue the C-105.2, not brokers, and the Board itself can’t issue certificates to a business. Businesses that aren’t required to carry coverage use Form CE-200, which the Board says can only be shown to a government agency, not to another business.

Before you request a COI, have ready

  • The exact legal name and mailing address of the certificate holder (for a permit, the building department’s address)
  • A copy of the insurance section of your contract
  • Any wording they want (additional insured, waiver of subrogation, primary and noncontributory)
  • The job or project name if they ask for it

Common hold-ups

  • An expired policy date on the certificate
  • Limits below what the contract requires
  • A missing additional-insured endorsement
  • An ACORD form sent where a New York workers’ comp form was needed

Next step

If a contract or permit is asking for certificates, ask My Compass Group Inc. to review the insurance requirements against your current policies. Coverage, endorsements and eligibility depend on the insurer and your business.

Want to compare your options?

Click the button below to head to our quotes page where you can enter some basic information to have our team help with your insurance!

Ready to get started?

Start Your Quotes Today

Enter some basic information below to get the process started.

Service Options